Solving Complex Family Law Issues with Creative Strategies

Contentious Divorce? How California Courts Handle High-Conflict Property Division Disputes

If you’re already going through the stress of dissolving your marriage, any additional concerns about losing valuable assets, protecting hard-earned investments, and ensuring a stable financial future can feel overwhelming. But whether you’re dealing with a spouse who refuses to cooperate or may be hiding assets, an experienced California family lawyer can help you protect your rights and secure a favorable outcome in your divorce.

What is Considered Community Property and Separate Property in California?

In California, community property – sometimes referred to as marital property – includes all of the assets and debts that either spouse acquired during the course of the marriage.

Community or marital property can encompass a wide range of possessions, including real estate, vehicles, bank accounts, retirement savings, investments, and even intellectual property or business ownership interests.

In contrast, separate property includes assets owned by either individual spouse before the marriage or acquired after marriage by gifts or inheritance.

This distinction is critical in divorce cases because community property is subject to equal division by California courts. Any community property gets split 50/50 between each spouse. As a result, determining which assets and debts count as community versus separate property can commonly become a point of contention between divorcing spouses – especially in cases where assets have been mixed or commingled.

What If You and Your Spouse Cannot Agree on Property Division?

When divorcing spouses cannot agree on how to divide their marital property, California courts must often intervene to make a final decision on their behalf. In contentious divorces, this process can involve detailed investigations into the financial histories of both parties, especially if there are allegations of hidden assets or mismanagement of marital funds.

You may explore mediation or collaborative divorce as an alternative option to a negotiated settlement. These processes allow you to work with neutral third-party professionals in the hopes of reaching a settlement outside of court. However, in cases where mediation fails or isn’t feasible because of the level of conflict, divorce litigation becomes the next step.

During litigation, both sides will present evidence and arguments before a judge, who will then determine how to divide the marital property – along with any other decisions that need to be made relating to child custody, child support, or spousal support.

When you go to court to resolve your divorce, the judge’s decision will take into account all of the relevant factors that you’ve presented, but the outcome may not necessarily be what either you or your spouse envisioned. This is why it’s critical to have skilled legal counsel by your side to ensure that your rights are protected and that all assets are accounted for properly.

How Do California Courts Approach Property Division in Divorce?

California’s community property law mandates that all community property, assets, and debts accumulated during the marriage must be divided equally between both spouses. While this may seem straightforward, contentious divorces often become far more complex because of disputes over valuation, disagreements over asset classification, or accusations of financial misconduct.

High-conflict or contested divorces may get complicated when spouses disagree over:

  • Classification of Marital Assets – Disputes over whether certain assets, such as a business or a valuable piece of real estate, belong to one party exclusively or to both.
  • Valuation of Assets – In many contentious cases, spouses may hotly contest the valuation of specific assets such as real estate, investments, or a business. Courts may appoint financial experts to appraise certain assets to ensure a fair division.
  • Debt Division – If one spouse accumulated debt irresponsibly or without the other’s knowledge during the marriage, this can complicate the debt division process.

Can You Keep the Family Home in a Contentious Divorce?

For many divorcing couples, the family home is not only their largest financial asset but it also holds deep emotional significance. As a result, determining who gets to keep the family home can become a major point of conflict in a contentious divorce.

In contentious divorces, one spouse may refuse to sell the home or alternatively seek to delay the sale of the home. When there is no agreement regarding the house being assigned to one spouse or the other, the court may order the property to be sold and divide the proceeds as necessary. Having an experienced divorce attorney is crucial in protecting your interest in the family home, whether you’re hoping to keep it or get fair compensation in exchange for relinquishing your rights to the property.

What Happens When One Spouse Hides Assets During a Divorce?

Hiding assets during a divorce isn’t just unethical, it’s also illegal. California law requires full disclosure of all your assets – and failure to do so can have severe legal consequences.

Unfortunately, in contentious divorces, one spouse may attempt to conceal property or income in an effort to skew the division of assets in their favor. If you suspect that your spouse is hiding assets, you can take legal action to protect yourself. Courts rely on accurate financial information to make fair rulings and any deceit can distort this process.

Common tactics used in divorce to hide assets include:

  • Underreporting income, leaving out sources of income, or exaggerating debts
  • Transferring assets to friends, family members, or business associates
  • Creating fake loans or debts to reduce personal wealth
  • Using offshore accounts or hidden bank accounts
  • Undervaluing business interests, properties, or investments

In such cases, forensic accountants or financial experts can be brought in to investigate suspicious financial activity and uncover any hidden assets. If a court finds that your spouse has intentionally concealed assets, the penalties for them could be severe – including awarding a larger share of the discovered assets to you or imposing legal sanctions or fines on them.

Because hiding assets undermines the integrity of the divorce process, California courts take the offense seriously. If you believe your spouse isn’t being transparent about their financial situation, a skilled divorce attorney can take the appropriate legal steps to ensure that all of their assets are disclosed and divided fairly amongst you.

What Role Do Prenuptial or Postnuptial Agreements Play in Asset Division?

Prenuptial and postnuptial agreements allow you to outline how your assets and debts will be handled in the event of a separation or divorce with your spouse. While prenuptial agreements are created before a marriage, postnuptial agreements serve the same purpose but are drafted and executed during a marriage and before your divorce.

If your nuptial agreement is valid and enforceable under California law, courts will generally use the agreement to determine how property is allocated in your divorce. These agreements can specify:

  • Which assets are considered separate property and are not subject to division
  • How specific assets or debts will be divided, including business interests, real estate, intellectual property, or investments

For these agreements to hold up in court, they must meet certain legal standards. In a contentious divorce, your spouse may try to invalidate your nuptial agreement, particularly if it puts them at a financial disadvantage. To check for validity, California family courts will examine prenuptial and postnuptial agreements to ensure that they were executed voluntarily and with full knowledge of each spouse’s financial situation. Agreements can be challenged if:

  • One spouse was coerced into signing or lacked proper legal representation
  • The agreement was unconscionable or grossly unfair at the time it was signed
  • Either spouse failed to provide full disclosure of their assets at the time of the agreement

If you have a prenuptial or postnuptial agreement in place, it’s important to consult with an attorney who can review the document and advise you on how it will impact your divorce proceedings. Conversely, if you’re challenging an agreement, an experienced lawyer can help you build a case for why the agreement should not be enforced.

How Can You Ensure a Fair Outcome in a Contentious Divorce?

Ensuring a fair outcome in a contentious divorce can be challenging, especially when emotions run high and both parties have conflicting interests. However, you can significantly improve your chances of reaching an equitable resolution by taking certain steps.

  1. Work With a Skilled Divorce Attorney – One of the most important steps you can take is to hire a divorce lawyer with experience in handling contentious cases. Your lawyer will help you navigate complex legal procedures, advocate on your behalf, and level the playing field during negotiations or court proceedings.
  2. Gather Comprehensive Financial Documents – Collect all of your relevant financial records, including bank statements, tax return, investment accounts, retirement accounts, property appraisals, and documentation of debts. Clear and organized financial records provide the court with an accurate picture of your marital assets, making it harder for the other party to hide assets or misrepresent their finances.
  3. Consider Mediation or Collaborative Divorce – In some cases, you may be able to reach a more favorable and less stressful outcome through mediation or collaborative divorce than through litigation. These processes allow both spouses to work with neutral professionals to reach mutually agreeable solutions without going to court. Although these alternatives may not be suitable for all contentious divorces, they can provide couples with a more efficient and less adversarial approach to resolving issues such as property division or child custody.
  4. Stay Focused on the Big Picture – Divorces can often become battles over small, emotionally charged issues that detract from the more important aspects of your case, such as protecting your financial stability. Don’t allow minor disagreements to sidetrack negotiations. By maintaining a clear focus on your long-term goals, you can avoid unnecessary delays and reach a resolution that protects your best interests.
  5. Prepare for the Possibility of Litigation – While settlement is often the preferred outcome, contentious divorces sometimes require litigation when you and your spouse simply cannot reach an agreement. Be prepared for the possibility that your case will go to trial. This involves gathering evidence, presenting a clear case on your behalf, and being ready to explain why your proposed property division is fair and equitable.
  6. Investigate Assets – In some contentious divorces, one spouse may attempt to hide assets to avoid dividing them fairly. If you suspect that your spouse is concealing property or income, you may need financial experts and forensic accountants to trace hidden assets and ensure that everything is accounted for in the final division.
  7. Remain Open to Compromise – While it’s natural to feel a sense of injustice during a contentious divorce, it’s important to remain calm and pragmatic throughout the process. Emotions can cloud your judgment or lead to rash decisions that may not serve your best interests. Being willing to compromise, when appropriate, can facilitate a quicker resolution and prevent the drawn-out stress and expense of a prolonged legal battle. But compromise should never come at the cost of fairness, and a good attorney will help you find the right balance between negotiation and standing firm on critical issues.
  8. Seek Emotional Support – Divorce, particularly in high-conflict situations, can be emotionally draining. Ensuring a fair outcome involves not only sound legal strategy but also mental resilience. Surround yourself with a strong support system, whether it’s family, friends, or a therapist, to help you navigate the emotional aspects of your divorce. A clear, focused mind allows you to make more rational decisions and avoid unnecessary escalation during the legal process.

At Moradi Saslaw, our law firm’s approach in contentious divorces is to pursue the best possible settlement for our clients while being fully prepared to litigate aggressively if necessary. We’re committed to securing outcomes that reflect your needs and financial goals, whether that involves negotiation or courtroom advocacy. Contact us now to get started on your case.


Ernest baello partner

Ernest Baello (Partner)

Ernest is a strong advocate and seasoned litigator, specializing in complex law actions in three of the largest metropolitan areas in the United States – the Bay Area, Los Angeles, and New York City.

Contact Us

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

/ Get The Right Legal Help
Start Here

Free consultation

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.